Unlocking Excellence in Schools: The Downsides of ‘Mentoring’ and the Benefits of ‘Coaching’

by Annie Boate

Unlocking Excellence in Schools: The Downsides of Traditional Mentoring and the Benefits of Coaching

Dear School Leaders,

In the realm of professional development, the traditional mentoring approach, often viewed as “the old way,” has its fair share of pitfalls that hinder true growth and empowerment. Let’s shine a light on these issues and explore why embracing coaching, “the new way,” is the key to overcoming these challenges and fostering a culture of innovation and self-sufficiency.

1. Dependency Dilemma:

• Mentoring (the old way): Promotes a dependency culture where individuals rely heavily on mentors.
• Coaching (the new way): Encourages autonomy and self-discovery, empowering individuals to find their unique solutions.

2. Directive Overload:

• Mentoring (the old way): Often adopts a ‘telling’ approach, inadvertently discouraging critical thinking.
• Coaching (the new way): Prioritises asking the right questions, nurturing a mindset of independent problem-solving.

3. One-Size-Fits-All Approach:

• Mentoring (the old way): Tends to be generic, neglecting the diverse challenges faced by individuals.
• Coaching (the new way): Specific to individual needs, recognising and addressing their unique challenges.

4. Disempowerment:

• Mentoring (the old way): Can create a dynamic where individuals feel disempowered to take charge.
• Coaching (the new way): Fosters a culture of empowerment, promoting proactivity and self-confidence.

5. Inadequate Problem-Solving:

• Mentoring (the old way): May not effectively equip individuals with problem-solving skills.
• Coaching (the new way): Provides tools for independent problem-solving, breaking the cycle of constant guidance-seeking.

6. Resistance to Change:

• Mentoring (the old way): Conditions individuals to resist change, hindering adaptability.
• Coaching (the new way): Encourages adaptability and innovation by fostering a growth mindset.

7. Lack of Ongoing Support:

• Mentoring (the old way): Often lacks consistent, ongoing support mechanisms.
• Coaching (the new way): Offers continuous support, ensuring individuals have the necessary tools to navigate challenges.

Coaching, as the new paradigm, proves to be a catalyst for transformative growth, addressing the shortcomings of traditional mentoring. It promotes a coaching culture that cultivates independence, critical thinking, and ongoing development. In the journey toward excellence, it’s time to embrace the new way – coaching – and witness the positive impact on your school’s development culture.

If you’d like to learn more, click/tap here now and book in a chat with our Director of School Improvement at a time that suits you.

mentoring vs coaching in schools

Leave a Reply