Risk Alert: Instructional Coaching’s Hidden Pitfalls Holding Schools Back

by Annie Boate

Risk Alert: Instructional Coaching’s Hidden Pitfalls Holding Schools Back

Dear Headteachers,

Embarking on a journey of professional development often involves navigating through terms like “instructional coaching.” However, it’s essential to unveil the reality beneath the surface – what is labelled as ‘coaching’ is, in fact, more closely aligned to ‘mentoring’. Understanding this distinction is crucial, as it sheds light on the limitations of instructional ‘coaching’ and underscores the pressing need for a genuine coaching system in your school.

Your commitment to improving teaching and learning is commendable. However, it’s pivotal to acknowledge that instructional coaching, i.e., mentoring, might inadvertently impede the growth and sustainability you aspire to achieve.

1. Dependency Dynamics:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): Can unintentionally foster a dependency culture, where individuals heavily rely on their mentor.
  • Genuine Coaching: Focuses on fostering autonomy and self-discovery, empowering individuals to find unique solutions independently.

2. Directive Tendencies and Resistance to Change:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): May adopt a ‘telling’ approach, inadvertently hindering critical thinking, creating resistance to change.
  • Genuine Coaching: Prioritises asking the right questions, nurturing a mindset of independent problem-solving, and fostering adaptability in the face of change.

3. One-Size-Fits-All Traps:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): May adopt a ‘telling’ approach, inadvertently hindering critical thinking, creating resistance to change.
  • Genuine Coaching: Prioritises asking the right questions, nurturing a mindset of independent problem-solving, and fostering adaptability in the face of change.

4. Empowerment Limitations:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): Risks creating a dynamic where individuals feel disempowered to take charge, with pressure on the mentor to be the expert.
  • Genuine Coaching: Promotes a culture of empowerment, allowing individuals to proactively take control of their development journey, and understanding that there are multiple paths to success.

5. Problem-Solving Effectiveness:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): May not effectively equip individuals with problem-solving skills, because the mentor’s way may not work for everyone.
  • Genuine Coaching: Provides tools for independent problem-solving, acknowledging the uniqueness of each situation and individual, and fostering a diverse range of effective approaches.

6. Adaptability Challenges:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): Can condition individuals to resist change, hindering adaptability.
  • Genuine Coaching: Encourages adaptability and innovation by fostering a growth mindset, recognising the diversity of effective approaches, and embracing change as a constant.

7. Sustainable Support Systems:

  • Instructional Coaching (i.e., Mentoring): Often lacks consistent, ongoing support mechanisms.
  • Genuine Coaching: Offers continuous support, ensuring individuals have the necessary tools to navigate challenges, embracing the uniqueness of each teacher’s journey, and acknowledging that growth is an ongoing process.

‘Instructional coaching’, perceived as coaching, can be deemed the “old way” and the “slow way.” Here’s why:

  • Rapid Educational Evolution: In today’s fast-paced educational landscape, relying on the traditional methods of mentoring via instructional coaching may impede progress. Genuine coaching adapts swiftly to changes, fostering a culture of continuous improvement.
  • Diversity of Teaching Approaches: The old way assumes a singular approach to teaching, while the new way acknowledges that each teacher is unique. Genuine coaching supports diverse teaching methods, recognising that what works for one may not work for another.
  • Empowerment for Long-Term Success: Instructional coaching, with its tendency to create dependency, might offer short-term solutions. Genuine coaching empowers individuals for long-term success, ensuring they become confident, independent, and proactive educators.

As you consider the dynamics of mentoring (via ‘instructional coaching’), versus genuine coaching, recognise that the shift is not just a shift in terminology; it’s a TRANSFORMATIVE leap toward a culture of continuous improvement and innovation in teaching and learning.

#CoachingExcellence #EducationalLeadership #EmpowerThroughGenuineCoaching #coachinginschools #awardwinningcoachingmodel #educationcoaching


If you’d like to learn more, click here and download a free excerpt from our book, which became a Number #1 Best-Seller!

ALERT-instructional-coaching-pitfalls-holding-schools-back

Leave a Reply

Top